From March 2027, new restrictions will make it automatically unfair to dismiss employees for refusing certain contractual changes, subject to a narrow financial difficulties exemption. These new limits are set out under the Employment Rights Act 2025. Until then, employers can still use the practice as a last resort, but must do so in a fair way.
What constitutes fire and rehire?
Fire and rehire, legally known as dismissal and re-engagement, is when you dismiss an employee from their existing contract, then offer them a new one – normally with less favourable terms and conditions. Employers often use this approach when they are forced to reduce operating costs, restructure working arrangements, change shift patterns, revise benefits, or introduce greater flexibility across their workforce.
Let’s say a business is under financial pressure and needs to either reduce contractual working hours, remove certain allowances, or change working patterns. If the employees don’t agree to the proposed changes, bosses might consider terminating existing contracts and offering re-employment on the revised terms.
This is counted as a dismissal, even if the employee accepts the new contract and continues working for the same organisation. On the other hand, employers can’t assume that retaining the individual removes any legal risks.
There is also an important distinction between fire and rehire and a genuine redundancy. If a business needs fewer employees, or doesn’t need people in specific roles any more, that is probably a genuine redundancy situation. Getting rid of someone just because they won’t accept contractual changes isn’t automatically a redundancy.
Just to confirm, fire and rehire is not illegal in the UK, but is becoming more restricted from the proposed date of March 2027. Until then, employers must follow the existing unfair dismissal law and the statutory code of practice on dismissal and re-engagement.
What are the alternatives to fire and rehire?
Employers who are facing genuine financial or operational challenges should prioritise finding a way to achieve their objectives without resorting to dismissals. And that’s not just about reducing the legal risk, it’s also about retaining valuable employees, protecting insider knowledge, and maintaining trust during uncertain times.
Check out these 5 alternatives:
1. Meaningful consultation and negotiation
It’s vital to have an open conversation in order to engage with employees and their representatives, explaining why the changes are needed, what the changes are designed to achieve, and what can happen if no agreement is reached.
Sharing the evidence behind proposals can help employees to understand the commercial pressures involved. Employees can suggest alternatives that achieve the same outcome but with less disruption, such as a temporary reduction in working hours or voluntary changes to shift patterns. Employers should consider whether different arrangements need to apply to different teams, so it’s not a one-size-fits-all approach across the whole of the organisation.
2. Redeployment
Before dismissals are considered, employers should look at the skills and experience already established across their workforce. Could employees be redeployed into other roles or to a different department? This can be particularly valuable if businesses are restructuring, consolidating functions, or changing the way that work is delivered.
Redeployment can help to retain employees who know the organisation, its customers and its culture inside out, reducing recruitment costs and the loss of valuable institutional knowledge. Where redundancies are genuine, employers must think about suitable alternative employment for impacted staff before letting them go.
3. Voluntary and flexible arrangements
Some employees may consider changes if they’re given flexibility and genuine options that work, such as reducing hours voluntarily, job sharing, temporary changes to working arrangements, unpaid leave, or a sabbatical. Employers can consider voluntary redundancy if there is a real need to reduce staff.
The point to remember here is that contractual changes should be agreed, not just imposed. Employers need to ensure that employees understand any implications around salary, pension contributions, benefits, or future entitlements before accepting any new arrangements.
4. Retraining and career development
Sometimes, the skills required don’t disappear, they change. That’s certainly true across AI and tech jobs at the moment and for the foreseeable future. Investing in retraining and career development can help workers to move into different roles, which means the business is able to retain experienced people. For organisations facing complex restructuring, exploring these alternatives to redundancies can help identify options that protect workforce capability and the employee experience.
5. Genuine redundancy and appropriate outplacement support
Of course, there will be situations where redundancies are inevitable. If roles genuinely disappear or the business needs fewer employees to carry out particular duties, a properly managed redundancy process will be necessary. When employees leave, outplacement support can provide help with CV writing, preparing for interviews, and seeking out new employment opportunities. The way an organisation treats departing colleagues sends a powerful message about its values to the staff who remain.
The fire and rehire statutory code of practice
The statutory code of practice, which came into force in July 2024, sets out how employers should approach proposed contractual changes where dismissal and re-engagement is being considered. It applies in England, Scotland, and Wales, and doesn’t take into account the number of affected employees or the reason for the changes.
Additionally, it doesn’t apply if the only reason for dismissal is genuine redundancy. The code states that employers must take all reasonable steps to explore alternatives to dismissals, and engage in meaningful consultations with employees.
In practical terms, employers should:
- Share information about the proposed changes, explaining the reasons and potential impact.
- Consult fully with employees, trade unions, or employee representatives where appropriate.
- Allow enough time for meaningful discussions and feedback.
- Consider alternative proposals and compromises.
- Re-examine the business case in the light of any employee feedback.
- Avoid using the threat of dismissal to put pressure on employees.
- Consider dismissal and re-engagement as a last resort.
There are also separate collective consultation obligations to take into account. If an employer wants to dismiss and rehire 20 or more employees at one establishment within 90 days, it must consult with the relevant trade unions or employee representatives.
Consultation must begin in good time, which translates to at least 30 days before the first dismissal for 20 to 99 employees, and 45 days for 100 or more staff. Failure to comply with this can result in a protective award of up to 180 days’ pay per affected employee, following an increase from 90 days in April 2026.
The UK government is also consulting on a replacement code, with the existing code expected to be revoked when the new fire and rehire protections take effect from March 2027 and a replacement code scheduled for the summer of 2027.
The business impact of getting it wrong
The legal fallout for mishandling the fire and rehire process is significant, but the longer term impact on employee engagement and organisational culture could be just as devastating for your company. If your employees feel that changes were imposed upon them without proper consultation, they may lose confidence in the leadership team, become disengaged, and feel the need to jump ship.
Careerminds carried out some research in the US, which discovered that trust in senior leadership fell by 18.4% immediately after a slew of redundancies. That’s a huge loss of confidence, particularly when businesses depend on employees to support a new direction or deliver organisational change.
But it does reinforce the importance of considering the human impact. A short-term, cost-saving measure that damages employee trust, drives off talent, and creates a long period of uncertainty could be a false economy, proving to be more expensive in the long term.
What should employers do now?
With these new protections due to take effect in March 2027, now is the time to review your approach to contractual changes. That means understanding which contractual terms could be affected, reviewing existing employment contracts, assessing the business case for proposed changes, and ensuring the HR department understands their obligations.
It would also be worth reviewing workforce planning and career development strategies, to identify opportunities for redeployment, reskilling, and internal mobility, before decisions about any dismissals are made.
Final thought
The Employment Rights Act doesn’t prevent firms from adapting to ever-shifting commercial circumstances, but it does make it increasingly important to show that employees, at every level, have been treated fairly and that all the alternatives have been explored.
So the question you should be asking yourself is whether you’ve done enough to retain the workers who will steer the business to success in the years to come.
More from Careerminds
Do you require outplacement support?
People are our priority. That is why we have customised talent management solutions at competitive prices that work across every level.